| Jared
Bourgeois - George M. Cohan |
| Barrett Goldsmith
- Jerry Cohan |
| Emily Latour
- Nellie Cohan |
| Katie Purcell -
Josie |
| Powdy Powdrell
- E.F. Albee |
| Mandy Thomas
- Ethel Levey |
| Anne Clarke
- Agnes Nolan |
| Jacqueline
Richards - Fay Templeton |
| Angie Payne -
Rose (Fay Templeton's Maid) |
| Alexis Fewell -
Mrs. Red Deer |
| Jonathan Jones -
Dr. Webb |
| Tara Peacock
- Mrs. Baker |
| Chris Harris -
Ben |
| Bobby Kirkpatrick
- Freddie (Fay Templeton's Manager) |
| Denise Williamson,
Sarah Salinas, Addie Robinson, Alexis Fewell, Megan Corcoran
- Pushcart Girls |
| Kevin Pierson -
Hank |
| Danny Kirkwood
- Sam Harris |
| Jenny Haslund
- Ma Templeton |
| Chris Shields -
Archie |
| Paula Brown
- Madame Grimaldi |
| Kevin Pierson
- Hank |
| B.J. Warminski -
Behman |
| Jessica Richards
- Secretary (in Cohan & Harris office) |
| Cameron Waldner
- Mayor Horbart T. Harty |
| Sean Huss -
Uncle Sam |
| Cody Easterbrook
- Walt |
| David Segrera,
Bobby Kirkpatrick, Chris Harris, B.J. Warminski - Harrigan
Singers |
| David Segrera
- Director |
| Denise Williamson -
Little Girl with Secretary |
| Grover as Himself
- Grover, the Dog |