The Best Supporting Actor and Actress Scholarship goes to the graduating seniors selected by the directors for having demonstrated an outstanding performance in a supporting role in the current musical production. The award is presented following the second Saturday night's performance. Prior to 1997, this scholarship was known as the Trusty Best Supporting Actor and Actress Scholarship.

2011 - Abbey Griffon, Joshua Karam 2001 - Sarah Salinas, Todd Norris 2010 - Michelle Wallace, Benjamin Watt 2000 - Emily Latour, Cody Easterbrook 2009 - Rachel Davidson, Derek Schilling 1999 - Meredith Savage, John Panzarella 2008 - Heather Limmer, Seth Ramsey 1998 - Shauna McLean, Brian Jarrell 2007 - Kassie Parker, Baker Goldsmith 1997 - Truley Welch, Shawn Pace 2006 - Trudy Taylor, Tyler Millen 1996 - Wendy Ward, Christopher Ming 2005 - Eryn Pendley, Eric Van Hal 1995 - Stephanie Schmutz, Richie Ramsey 2004 - Alison Hunter 1994 - Courtney F. Wissinger, Mark D. Posey 2003 - Sami Montemayor, Brian Y'Barbo 1993 - Julie Candy, Sterling Schmutz 2002 - Rachel Kyle, Luke Kirkwood 1992 - Angie Rodgers, Dan Seckel